The winner of the Reserves Best and Fairest vote count each season is awarded the Ian McKenzie Medal.
The winner of the Colts Best and Fairest vote count each season is awarded the David Murrihy Medal.
| Year | Seconds Best & Fairest | Thirds Best & Fairest |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Nathan Allen & Brenden Rapisarda | No team fielded |
| 2023 | Dylan Dower | No team fielded |
| 2022 | Nathan Allen | No team fielded |
| 2021 | Matt Geraghty | Lachie Wright |
| 2020 | Season Cancelled | Season Cancelled |
| 2019 | Nathan Allen | Jacob Delrayne |
| 2018 | Brett Castersen | Jake Mellis |
| 2017 | Jordan Granland | Dylan Dower |
| 2016 | Mitch Agars | Jayden Purdon |
| 2015 | Sean Bell & Dayne Ruff | Corey Burgess |
| 2014 | Josh Saker | Harry Burgess |
| 2013 | Declan Shiels | Brenton McAlpine |
| 2012 | Josh Temple | Mitch Goddard |
| 2011 | Josh Temple | Sam D'Argenio |
| 2010 | Mitchell Wright | Lachlan Watson |
| 2009 | Damien Ravenhorst | Jordan Veness |
| 2008 | Chris Devenish | Luke Leeson |
| 2007 | Tom McNamara | Declan Shiels & Nick Allen |
| 2006 | Ben Van Dort | Troy Hudson |
| 2005 | Dean Grice | |
| 2004 | Matt Heenan | Dean Grice |
| 2003 | Drew Griffin | Ben Van Dort |
| 2002 | Dennis Campbell | Luke Crawley |
| 2001 | Robert Kimmitt | Ben Hoey |
| 2000 | Robert Kimmitt | James Ross |
| 1999 | Robert Kimmitt | Luke Atkinson |
| 1998 | Colin Krenn | Lukas Appleby |
| 1997 | Cam Mellis | Justin Robertson |
| 1996 | ||
| 1995 | ||
| 1994 | ||
| 1993 | Brendan McNamara | |
| 1992 | ||
| 1991 | Glenn Mellis | Stuart Murley |
| 1990 | ||
| 1989 | David Rule | Matthew Kavanagh |
| 1988 | Nick Passmore | |
| 1987 | Dave Graffen | |
| 1986 | Dennis Ewing | Jeff Van Summeren |
| 1985 | Garry Tunstall | Garry Milne |
| 1984 | Brian Burmeister | |
| 1983 | Dillio Rech | Dean Carroll |
| 1982 | Glenn Cameron | |
| 1981 | Brendan Mutimer | |
| 1980 | Anthony "Tony" Eddy | Chris Burgess |
| 1979 | Adrian Papworth | |
| 1978 | Alasdair Gall | Paul Evans |
| 1977 | Dillio Rech | Gary Lewis |
| 1976 | D. Parry | Ray Lacey |
| 1975 | D. Beckton (Dave?) | Ray Lacey |
| 1974 | Ray Nicholds | Ian Russell |
| 1973 | Dennis Plymin | David Murrihy |
| 1972 | Phil Conboy | Kevin Hayward |
| 1971 | ||
| 1970 | Dave Turner | |
| 1969 | Dave Boulton | |
| 1968 | Ian Lester | |
| 1967 | ||
| 1966 | ||
| 1965 | Bernie McCoy | John Gretton |
| 1964 | C. Richardson (Charlie?) | |
| 1963 | William "Bill" Warren | |
| 1962 | Don Richards | |
| 1961 | William "Bill" Warren | |
| 1960 | Gordon Lewer | C. Doyle |
| 1959 | ||
| 1958 | Ivan Nicol | Bruce Thompson |
| 1957 | G. Herring | Peter Alexander |
| 1956 | Ron Downward | Ivan Nicol |
| 1955 | Ivan Nicol |